In Our ImageAncient Stories. Modern Lives. Familiar Struggles.
25 - David & GoliathPrint
Story 25·1 Samuel 17

David & Goliath

What does courage look like when the odds really are against you?
CourageFearTrustWisdom
Movement I of IV
The story
What the text says happened, before anyone tells you what it means.
The story

The Philistine and Israelite armies camp on two hills with a valley between them. A heavily armed Philistine champion, Goliath of Gath, dares Israel to send one man to fight him.

He repeats the challenge morning and evening for forty days. King Saul and his army are terrified.

David, the youngest of Jesse's sons, brings food to his brothers at the front. He hears the challenge, asks about it openly, and his eldest brother rebukes him in anger.

Saul sends for him. David offers to fight, cites a lion and a bear he killed, takes off the armor Saul gives him, and goes out with his staff, a sling and five stones.

David runs at Goliath and strikes him in the forehead with a stone. He kills him with Goliath's own sword and cuts off his head. The Philistines flee and Israel gives chase.

1 Samuel 17:11
“When Saul and all Israel heard those words of the Philistine, they were dismayed, and greatly afraid.”
Movement II of IV
The pattern
What may be happening underneath the events, with each reading marked for how firmly the text supports it.
Story to psychology

What's happening underneath?

A few possible ways to read the human behavior in the story.
Saul and the army hear Goliath and are badly afraid; later the men run from him (17:11, 17:24).
Grounded in the text
The chapter spends its words for fear on the king and his soldiers. David is described through what he says and does.
Goliath repeats his challenge morning and evening for forty days (17:16).
A plausible reading
The same challenge, twice a day, with no taker. It reads like a threat the camp has learned to live around rather than answer.
David takes off Saul's armor and goes out with his staff, sling and stones (17:38-40).
Grounded in the text
The one reason he gives is that he has not tested the armor. He leaves it and goes out with his own gear instead.
David asks twice about the reward, but every reason he gives is about Israel's disgrace and God (17:25-30, 17:45-47).
A speculative reading
The reward could have sat alongside the cause in his thinking. That stays a guess, and it does not make the act less brave.

One camp got used to being afraid.

Two armies face each other across the valley of Elah. Morning and evening for forty days, the Philistine champion Goliath walks out in bronze armor with the same offer. Send one man. If he kills me, we serve you. If I kill him, you serve us.

Saul and all Israel hear it and are badly afraid. When Goliath appears, the men run. Saul's answer is a rich reward for whoever will fight. Under Goliath's terms, a king who fought in person would stake the whole army on himself.

David asks out loud, and keeps asking.

David has not come as a soldier. His father sent him with food for his brothers. He arrives, hears the challenge, and the men around him run. Then he asks out loud what will be done for the man who kills this Philistine and lifts Israel's disgrace.

His eldest brother Eliab turns on him in anger: you are proud, you only came to watch the battle. The narrator never rules on that charge. David answers with a question of his own, what has he done now, and turns to the next man with the same question until his words reach Saul.

He asks twice about the reward: riches, the king's daughter, freedom for his father's house. But every reason he gives is about Israel's disgrace and a challenge to the living God. The chapter keeps both in plain view.Evidence note 1

He leaves the borrowed armor behind.

Saul objects that David is a youth and Goliath has been a fighting man since his own youth. It is a fair reading of the odds. David answers with a record: a lion and a bear took a lamb from his father's flock, and he went after them and killed them.

Saul puts his own armor on him. David tries to walk in it, says he has not tested it, and takes it off. He goes out with his staff, a sling and five smooth stones. Ancient slings could kill, but the narrator still stresses the gap: there was no sword in David's hand.

David does not credit his own skill. The LORD who saved him from the lion and the bear, he says, will save him from this Philistine, because the battle is the LORD's. A tested record and chosen tools on one side; his insistence that it is the LORD who delivers, on the other. Both stand.Evidence note 2

The text never says what he felt.

Fear gets named twice in this chapter, in Saul's camp and in the men who run. For David there is only speech and action. He volunteers, argues, picks his gear and runs toward Goliath.

The common reading is that trust in God gave him courage, and his own words make that fair. Psychologist Cynthia Pury offers a second angle: courage is choosing to act toward a worthwhile goal despite a known risk. Fear is common but not required, and its absence is not the test. If that is right, you do not have to wait to feel brave.Evidence note 3Evidence note 4

The deeper idea

Courage is often less a feeling you wait for than a decision to act with what you have actually tested, in a place where everyone else has got used to being afraid.

Movement III of IV
The mirror
Where the story stops being about them and starts being about you.
From the story

Lines worth sitting with.

1 Samuel 17:16 KJV
“And the Philistine drew near morning and evening, and presented himself forty days.”
1 Samuel 17:48 KJV
“And it came to pass, when the Philistine arose, and came and drew nigh to meet David, that David hasted, and ran toward the army to meet the Philistine.”
The uncomfortable part

We only see the stone that hits.

The chapter tells the version where the stone lands. That win is what makes David's run look like courage rather than recklessness. Before the fight, Saul's objection was reasonable, and even Saul set it aside when he sent David out. We never see the other version.

Nor does it end cleanly. David uses Goliath's own sword to kill him and cut off his head, carries the head to Jerusalem, and keeps the armor in his tent. Only after the champion falls does Israel's army rise up and give chase. Courage here comes with no guarantee and no tidy ending. Maybe knowing that going in is part of the choice.Evidence note 5

What's yours?

Choose what is yours to choose.

Outside your control
  • Goliath's size, armor and contempt (17:4-7, 17:42-44)
  • Whether Eliab or Saul would believe him (17:28, 17:33)
  • Any guarantee of where the stone would land (17:49)
Still yours
  • Asking the question aloud despite his brother's anger (17:28-30)
  • Refusing untested armor and taking his sling and stones (17:38-40)
  • Running toward the threat instead of waiting (17:48)
David chose to ask out loud, to take off the armor, to pick up five stones, and to run. He could not choose Goliath's size, Eliab's scorn or Saul's doubt, and he could not guarantee where the stone would land.
Try the same split with whatever you are facing. Then ask where you might be wearing someone else's armor: a method or title you took on because it carries weight, not because you have tried it. What have you already tested, even in fights nobody watched?
Movement IV of IV
What remains
The tension the story refuses to resolve, and the question it leaves with you.
The part that doesn't resolve neatly

You can act before this is settled.

Was the reward part of David's thinking, beside Israel's disgrace and God's honor? Is what he stands on trust in God, a tested record, or both at once? The chapter leaves both open. If you are waiting for your own motives to feel pure before you move, it is worth asking whether the waiting has become the reason you never do.

You may also have your own forty days: a challenge at work, at home or in your town, repeated so often that nobody questions it anymore. Someone gets to be the first to ask about it out loud.Evidence note 6

What the text doesn't say

The chapter leaves some questions open.

Some of the most interesting gaps in this story come right where readers most want an answer. Here are four of them. We point to where each one sits and leave it open.

  1. Where it sits: 1 Samuel 17:17-18, 1 Samuel 17:20, 1 Samuel 17:28-29

    Did David have any reason for coming beyond his father's errand?

    If Jesse's errand was the whole reason David came, Eliab's anger lands on an innocent man. If he also wanted to see the battle, his questions in camp read differently. Either way, his choice matters.

  2. Where it sits: 1 Samuel 17:32, 1 Samuel 17:33-37, 1 Samuel 17:48

    What was David feeling when he ran at Goliath?

    Saul tells him the danger to his face, and David answers with an argument about the lion and the bear. What went on inside him, the chapter keeps to itself. Knowing would help us tell sound judgment from boldness that only looks wise because it worked.

  3. Where it sits: 1 Samuel 17:25-27, 1 Samuel 17:30

    Did the reward play any part in his decision?

    He asks about it twice, but every reason he gives is about Israel's disgrace and God. Whether, and how much, the riches and the king's daughter weighed with him changes how we hear his speech. It does not change what he did.

  4. Where it sits: 1 Samuel 17:38-39, 1 Samuel 17:55-58

    Why does Saul ask whose son David is, after putting his own armor on him?

    Saul arms David, then asks whose son he is. The Greek version of the chapter lacks this inquiry entirely; one possible explanation is that two tellings were joined. Scholars disagree about the textual history, so the gap stays open.

Common misreadings

Some familiar versions go further than the text.

This story has been told so often that parts of the retelling feel like scripture. Here are three popular readings, stated the way the people who hold them would put it, set beside what the chapter actually records.

  1. The familiar reading

    David walked out calm and unafraid. Everyone else was shaking, and he felt none of it. That calm is what made him a hero.

    What the text supports

    The chapter names fear in Saul and the army and nowhere else. It records nothing of what David felt. What it gives is conduct: he volunteers, argues his case, and runs toward Goliath. Calm may have been there, or fear. Either way, his courage shows in what he did.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:11, 1 Samuel 17:24, 1 Samuel 17:32, 1 Samuel 17:34-37, 1 Samuel 17:48

  2. The familiar reading

    Israel's soldiers were afraid because they had stopped trusting God. David had faith and they did not.

    What the text supports

    David tells Goliath that the LORD does not save with sword and spear. But the army fears a giant and runs when he appears. Saul objects on fighting experience: youth against a man who has been a warrior from his own youth. The text never traces the army's fear to lost faith.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:11, 1 Samuel 17:24, 1 Samuel 17:33, 1 Samuel 17:47

  3. The familiar reading

    Saul was a coward. He was the king and the man who should have fought, and he stayed back and sent a boy in his place.

    What the text supports

    Saul is afraid but this chapter passes no verdict. His doubt about a youth facing a lifelong warrior was fair. Goliath's terms also mattered: the loser's people would serve. The text never explains why Saul stayed back.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:9, 1 Samuel 17:11, 1 Samuel 17:33, 1 Samuel 17:42, 1 Samuel 17:56, 1 Samuel 17:58

Sit with this

What fear in your life has become so familiar it no longer feels like a choice, and what have you already tested that you could act with before you feel ready?

Show the evidence

Here is what the page stands on.

The main points above rest on something specific. Some rest on the words of the chapter. Others are fair readings of it, or ideas brought in from outside. The notes below say which is which.

  1. Note 1A reading

    SupportsBack to David asks out loud, and keeps asking.

    David asks his question openly in a camp that has heard the challenge for forty days and runs when Goliath appears. Eliab rebukes him. David keeps pressing until Saul hears. Calling this a social risk is our reading; the text never says what he thought it might cost.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:16, 1 Samuel 17:24, 1 Samuel 17:26, 1 Samuel 17:28-31

  2. Note 2In the text

    SupportsBack to He leaves the borrowed armor behind.

    David backs his offer with the lion and the bear. His only reason for rejecting Saul's armor is that he has not tested it. He takes his staff, sling and five stones. Whether practical, faithful, or both, remains open.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:34-36, 1 Samuel 17:39, 1 Samuel 17:40

  3. Note 3In the text

    SupportsBack to The text never says what he felt.

    The chapter describes fear twice: Saul and all Israel are dismayed, and the men run and are badly afraid. For David it records only speech and action. That gap is itself the evidence, and it does not tip toward fear or toward fearlessness.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:11, 1 Samuel 17:24, 1 Samuel 17:32, 1 Samuel 17:48

  4. Note 4A reading

    SupportsBack to The text never says what he felt.

    Pury defines courage as choosing to act toward a worthwhile goal despite a known risk. Fear is common but not required. This frames David's action but cannot tell us what he felt or what risk he recognized. We only know Saul told him the danger.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:32, 1 Samuel 17:33, 1 Samuel 17:48

  5. Note 5A reading

    SupportsBack to We only see the stone that hits.

    This rests on the story alone. The chapter tells only the version where the stone hits and Goliath falls. Before that, Saul's objection was a reasonable read of the odds. The victory is what makes David's choice read as courage rather than recklessness.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:33, 1 Samuel 17:49-51

  6. Note 6In the text

    SupportsBack to You can act before this is settled.

    The soldiers talk about the reward just before David speaks, and he asks about it twice. Every reason he actually gives is about Israel's disgrace, the defiance of the living God, and past rescues. Both sit side by side in the chapter, and it never says which one moved him.

    References: 1 Samuel 17:25-27, 1 Samuel 17:30, 1 Samuel 17:36-37, 1 Samuel 17:45-47